EUROPA: Rise of
the Carnelians
written by Jason Gehlert
published by Stonegarden
(2009)
ISBN:
1-60076-138-0
reviewed by Adam Armstrong
2.20.2009
Watch out for those
crazy dialog tags!
It is the year 2045
(though you wouldn’t know it because all culture references are about current
television, movies, and music) and the Yellowstone Caldera is getting ready to
erupt; killing off most of the population of the world. The first
African-American president, Jackson Forsythe, sends the world’s richest man,
Adrian Blakely, to gather up the smartest minds in the world (who all
apparently live in
There are some bad
books out there but this one has its eyes on the prize for the worst ever
written. The basic idea of the
This train-wreck of a
book brings up two important points:
The first is the
absolute need for editors in the publishing world. These guys and gals are the
underdogs that some writers sneer at. When you first start off trying to hone
your skills in the writing world with the short story market, editors are the
ones that say no to you and give you those great form rejections that don’t
seem to be any help. But in a way they’re telling you to work harder and try
again. I hate the crap about editors stifling creativity for commercial
viability that is heard by often rejected writers. It is the editor’s job to
bring out the best in your work. And commercial viability allows you to gain
more notoriety and finances in order to spend more time creating and giving you
a wider audience to speak with. Books such as this one clearly show that there
is little editor involvement if any.
The second point is
the need for research. Of all the genres to write in, Science Fiction is the
one that demands research the most. In Europa we’re never told why the spaceship has artificial
gravity or how the spacesuits work on such a cold satellite. Of course there
are tons of explanations that can be used for these subjects none are given.
When a writer can weave research in perfectly with the story, never drawing the
reader too far from the plot, the reading experience is so much more
satisfying. Also you come away from the book feeling the hard work that was put
into it. Any time you have something that you know is a product of hard work
and a strong work ethic you immediately add more value and even some respect to
it. I think it was a Rolling Stone article that said author Chuck Palahniuk
once read an entire reference book to add one sentence to the book he was
writing. This kind of dedication to your craft shows and is why authors like
Palahniuk, Clancy, Gerritsen, and hundreds more are
best selling authors.
Europa is a bad book but it
did bring about quite a few interesting thoughts for this reviewer.
1 out of 5
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Reviewed
by Scott M. Sandridge
8.7.10
The
story suffers from pages upon pages of info dump. By page 97 I was gritting my
teeth, yelling, “Enough of Yellowstone! I’m sick of hearing about
To
make matters worse, the main thrust of the story’s plot doesn’t even appear
until page 154, after the story is half over. The characters are little more
than clichéd caricatures, even though the dialogue had its good moments.
Unfortunately, one of the most suspenseful scenes had its suspense completely
robbed via being done as flashback in dialogue.
At
least there was a sex scene to look forward to; sort of. Except it was brief,
read like a boyhood fantasy, and that was before the “fade to black” moment.
Overall. One out of Five.